J.J. a 10th overall 2024 draft pick by the Vikings. He led Michigan, to a national championship under Jim Harbaugh. Rookie season he had a knee injury lost a year. In 2025 season he threw 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. This year he lost the staring job.
Is J.J. McCarthy worth trading for?
My heart says no because I don’t want anything to stop the New York Giants from drafting a quarterback this year. No matter what happens I want a new QB. My head though says, he is worth a 3rd day draft pick a 5th rounder.
Should he be ahead of Jamies Winston?
I say no. They are both known for turning the ball over but Jamies bring belief than you can win with him. J.J. on the NFL has never heard anyone say that about him.
New York Giants should draft a QB no matter what?
Yes Jaxson Dart cannot be trusted to be healthy. Like most relationships how it starts is usually how it ends. We just stop over looking flaws.
The Giants can’t pass on a generational QB for the generic QB who might be franchise worthy someday like Daniel Jones. It’s the and the love certain type people though.
Do you like this trade for the New York Giants?
Leave a Reply